Chapman House · City records

Documents released by the City

Historic-status, planning, permit, code-compliance, and correspondence records for the house.

City of Carmel-by-the-Sea
Public Records Request 26-180

APN 010-253-016 · Block HH, Lot 22
Downloaded 16 September 2026

These reading copies retain the City’s filenames and redactions. The City portal remains the official source.

View the official City request
01

Historic designation and City decisions

The 2006–07 appeal, the 2020–21 historic review, and the current inventory listing.

20 November 2006 HRB Agenda

The meeting agenda placing Virginia Hayes’s HA 05-9 appeal before the Historic Resources Board after the City identified the house for its Historic Resources Inventory.

20 November 2006 HRB Minutes

Records the Board’s denial of the appeal and its direction to remove Thomas Church as the identified garden designer from the DPR form.

9 January 2007 City Council Minutes

Records the Council’s decision to grant Virginia Hayes’s appeal, remove the property from the Historic Resources Inventory, and delete references to Thomas Church from the DPR form.

HA 05-9 — Hayes

The City Council appeal packet for removing the house from the inventory, including the staff summary, Historic Resources Board material, and discussion of the 1949 residence’s significance and alterations.

2021 Historic Resources Board Agenda Packet

The principal City packet for DS 20-285. It describes the house’s 2020 historic eligibility and evaluates the proposed 674-square-foot addition and 439-square-foot roof deck against the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards.

02

Planning applications and permits

The withdrawn addition proposal and later permits for repairs, building systems, fencing, and tree work.

PSA 19-436 — Preliminary Site Assessment

The initial file for remodeling the 757-square-foot residence, constructing an addition and roof deck, and conducting the historic review that found the house eligible for the inventory in August 2020.

DS 20-285 — Design Study

The full design-study record for a 674-square-foot rear addition, 439-square-foot roof deck, and spiral-stair access. The application was withdrawn on 21 September 2021.

BP 21-329 — Roof and Window Repairs

Building-permit record for roof replacement, repair of weather-damaged windows, fascia and trim, replacement skylights, and an electrical upgrade.

PP 22-178 — Boiler and Gas Line

Finaled plumbing permit for replacing the water boiler with a tankless hot-water boiler and removing and capping the gas line along the fence.

TR 25206 — Tree Pruning

Retroactive permit for pruning Cypress and other tree branches described as encroaching over the fence and presenting a fire concern. The permit is tied to Code Compliance Case #25164.

03

Code compliance

Closed municipal cases concerning building work and tree work at the property.

Code Compliance Case #22203

Building-violation record concerning an unpermitted water heater and gas piping along the fence. The case closed after the plumbing permit was obtained and the gas piping removed.

Code Compliance Case #25164

Tree-violation record concerning unpermitted Cypress cutting. It includes the stop-work history and closes after approval of retroactive Tree Permit TR 25206.

04

City correspondence and evaluations

Released email threads, completeness reviews, and the Phase Two historic evaluation for DS 20-285.

19 October 2020 — DS 20-285 Completeness Review

The planner’s email and attached review letter identifying conflicts with the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards, including concerns about the addition, rooftop deck, massing, and character-defining features.

3 November 2020 — San Antonio 3 SE of 4th

An internal City discussion about referring the project to a historic consultant, the correction letter, and prior communication with the Historic Resources Board concerning the roof deck and stair tower.

4 November 2020 — Historic Review Follow-up

A follow-up thread between the architect and City staff about the applicable historic-review process and clarification reportedly received from the Historic Resources Board chair.

19 November 2020 — Phase Two Evaluation

The City email chain and Margaret Clovis’s Phase Two report. It identifies the house’s historic significance and character-defining features and concludes that the proposed project would significantly affect the resource.